Cell phone notifications may be driving you to distraction

Whether you are alerted to an incoming phone call or text by a trendy ringtone, an alarm bell or a quiet vibration, just receiving a notification on your cell phone can cause enough of a distraction to impair your ability to focus on a given task.

In fact, the distraction caused by a simple notification is comparable to the effects seen when users actively use their cell phones to make calls or send text messages, the researchers found.

distracting effect cell phone notifications

Study shows message alerts are as disruptive as actually using phone

“The level of how much it affected the task at hand was really shocking,” said Courtney Yehnert, an Florida State University research coordinator who worked on the study as an undergraduate student before graduating in 2014.

The “study, published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance. This is the first study to examine the effect of cell phone notifications on performance.

“Although these notifications are generally short in duration, they can prompt task-irrelevant thoughts, or mind-wandering, which has been shown to damage task performance,” the researchers wrote in the paper. “Cellular phone notifications alone significantly disrupt performance on an attention-demanding task, even when participants do not directly interact with a mobile device during the task.”

Multitasking can lead to poorer performance

It’s well documented that using a mobile phone while performing another task is associated with poorer performance. That’s because people have limited capacity for attention that must be split between tasks, the researchers explained. The Florida State study underscores that simply being aware of a missed call or text can have the same effect.

Does putting down your phone crank up your anxiety?

text notificationThe researchers’ findings are significant because many public information campaigns intended to deter problematic cell phone use — while driving, for example — often emphasize waiting to respond to messages and calls. However, even waiting may take a toll on attention, according to the researchers. Simply remembering to perform some action in the future is sufficient to disrupt performance on an unrelated concurrent task.

>> Does putting down your phone crank up your anxiety?

To conduct the study, the researchers compared the performance of participants on an attention-demanding computer task, which was divided into two parts.

In the first part, participants were asked simply to complete the task. During the second part, although they were not aware of it, participants were randomly assigned to one of three groups: call, text or no notification. Automated calls and texts were then sent to the personal phones of participants in the first two groups without their knowledge that the notifications were coming from the researchers.

Overall, the researchers found that participants who received notifications made more mistakes on the computer task than those who didn’t. In fact, the increase in the probability of making a mistake was more than three times greater for those who received notifications. Those who received phone call notifications fared worse on the task than those who received a text alert.

Smartphones and attention performance

The researchers then compared their results to the findings of other studies that explored the impact that actually using a cell phone had on attention performance. They found their results were similar, suggesting that receiving a notification but not responding is as distracting as actually answering the phone or replying to a text.

That smartphone is giving your thumbs superpowers

>> 62% of kids think parents are too distracted to listen to them

Although the FSU study did not involve driving, the results are relevant to the problem of distracted driving, the researchers said.

“Even a slight distraction can have severe, potentially life-threatening effects if that distraction occurs at the wrong time,” says lead author and psychology doctoral student Cary Stothart. “When driving, it’s impossible to know when ‘the wrong time’ will occur. Our results suggest that it is safest for people to mute or turn off their phones and put them out of sight while driving.”

The researchers plan to follow this study with another that examines cell phone notification distraction while participants are given a driving test on a simulator.

More Stories
Save on medical bills: How to haggle with a doctor or hospital

Pin It on Pinterest