How big?! Yes, arachnophobes often overestimate spider size
In a finding that probably won’t surprise anybody who lives with a spider-hater, researchers have discovered that arachnophobes — people with a fear of spiders — tend to overestimate the size of the eight-legged creepy-crawlies they see.
“The spider was the size of my hand!”
Research reported in 2016 shows that arachnophobes overestimate spider size — especially when compared with other neutral animals that do not elicit fear. But this finding is more than just interesting or reassuring — it might actually be useful in treating phobias.
The study published in the journal, Biological Psychology, consisted of two experiments measuring attractiveness (valence) and the self-relevance role in neutral (birds, butterflies) vs. aversive (spiders) animal size estimation.
“We found that although individuals with both high and low arachnophobia rated spiders as highly unpleasant, only the highly fearful participants overestimated the spider size,” explains Dr Tali Leibovich, a PhD researcher at the Ben-Gurion University of the Negev (BGU) Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences and the Zlotowski Center for Neuroscience.
The research was born from a lab experience when Dr Noga Cohen noticed a spider crawling, and her spider-phobic colleague, Dr Leibovich, asked her to get rid of it. Cohen could not understand why Leibovich was afraid and thought the spider was small, while Leibovich insisted the spider was large.
“How could this be if we both saw the same spider?” asked Cohen.
In the study, the researchers had female BGU students complete a questionnaire that measured their fear of spiders and divided the participants into two groups: afraid and unafraid.
The results of the first experiment demonstrated that although both groups rated the spider pictures as more unpleasant than the other pictures, only the highly fearful participants overestimated the size of spiders compared to butterflies.
Further experiments showed that size estimation was affected by both the level of unpleasantness and the great fear a participant had of spiders.
“This study revealed how perception of even a basic feature such as size is influenced by emotion, and demonstrates how each of us experiences the world in a unique and different way,” says Leibovich.
“This study also raises more questions such as: Is it fear that triggers size disturbance, or maybe the size disturbance is what causes fear in the first place?,” she says. “Future studies that attempt to answer such questions can be used as a basis for developing treatments for different phobias.”